Below is a review worth rereading (or reading for the very first time). Robert Christgau was at the time he wrote this the music critic for Newsday, the Long Island daily. He has also written books and articles for Rolling Stone, Esquire , was the rock critic for The Village Voice and writes for several other pubs. You can hear him on your local NPR station and can find his work at his website. From the time we came across this a few years ago, it’s been one of our favorite reviews because Christgau knows his stuff and it’s an honest evaluation of Tom Jones in 1972.
In this piece he went to the Westbury Music Fair (now the North Fork Theater at Westbury) on Long Island which, as we’ve said before, seems to be one of Tom’s favorite venues and at which he’s performed fairly regularly since 1971. He’ll be back in November.
When this was written Tom played 13 shows — opening on a Friday, playing two shows a night Friday and Saturday, one each evening Sunday through Thursday and then two a night Friday and Saturday. And, since tickets were about $12, many fans went to all 13 shows for a total of $156. [NOTE: The "Inner Circle" about which he writes was the "club" people who patronized Westbury could join for $5 a year. That gave them access to early announcements and early ticket sales for Westbury shows.]
For these reviews, Christgau — who, as you’ll see, knows his music — took his mom to see Tom in April and Engelbert in May. The photo of Tom is from the next month, May 1972, at Caesars Palace in Las Vegas. The photo right is of Enzo Stuarti, a smooth Italian tenor who had success in the US back in the day.
Two Nights at the Westbury Music Fair
1. Tom Jones
There were seven women in Section A, Row F, behind us, and the woman with the aisle seat, right next to where his burly helpers would hustle him on and off the round stage, had earned her prize appropriately, with middle-class virtues. The very night she had received her Inner Circle bulletin, in January, she had ordered her tickets for Tom Jones’s opening night at the Westbury Music Fair. I had my seat by press privilege, and my mother, who accompanied me, had done nothing more strenuous than skip her church group to do so. She was acting very cool about it.
My mother is a sane, intelligent, demure woman with little interest in popular music, but as we eavesdropped on the women behind us, reminiscing about Elvis Presley and complaining about the plethora of uniformed guards, she got worried.
“I know this guy is going to get to me. I’m putting up a big front, but I know. I saw Enzo Stuarti and before it was over I was falling all over him, and you know what he is. It’s the ambiance.”
She was right, but she has nothing to worry about — she succumbed to talent. Jones is very good at what he does. He has one of the best voices in popular music — not one of your failed opera baritones, but a rich, husky ballad instrument with heavy black and country influences and that essential romantic Welsh fillip — and he knows how to use it. Not many singers could do such a wide variety of top-forty material — from Wilson Pickett to Al Green, from Frank Sinatra to Three Dog Night — so credibly. Only once, on Till, did he indulge in the overdramatizing most similar performers feel is obligatory.
(more…)