Sir Tom In Winnipeg: Don’t Know What To Say About These Reviews — “Clueless” Is The Least Of It
Tuesday, June 10th, 2008Wednesday evening, June 11: One more blog report from Canada that’s kind of nice. And it links to Tom’s fabu version of The Reason. Check it out.
Wednesday, June 11: Another review, this one from the Winnipeg Sun is more of the same. This time, Sir Tom is called an ” old crooner.” At the end of his piece, the reviewer allows, “We’re still not sure about the underwear, ladies, but we’re starting to understand what you see in this guy,” but it’s more of the same as below. Getting tiresome.

OK. We get it. Not everyone is a Tom Jones fan. But, sometimes, the things they write are so — well — stupid. Now, Ellen will tell you from her own experience that it’s easier to write a negative, sarcastic review than a positive one. And we certainly don’t expect every reviewer to love the show. But, despite all experience to the contrary, we’re always surprised when a reviewer — allegedly a person who knows music — doesn’t get it at all. By the third sentence (”Tom Jones inner real-life monologue”) she’d lost us. Add to that the description of the audience and the panty count and saying his career is built on “nary more than a waggle of his hips,” along with a description of the show as “easy-going traditionalist.” Well, there’s nothing else to say, is there?
(Except — those of you who would criticize us for getting annoyed about this stuff — please bear in mind that we review shows and we never stoop to this level. Again, honest criticism is fair and often warranted. But this is dishonest. And, worst of all, it’s not even funny. And do not doubt for a minute that she was going for funny.)
The only question we have is: should we continue to post this such reviews? We probably will, because they’re out there and from legitimate sources. But, we’d like your opinion. Please advise. Thanks. (To make up for this miserable review, we’re posting two photos by Mike Wachniak that really have nothing to do with this post. Except they are from Canada. They were taken at the June 2 fundraiser Tom did in Vancouver. At the left is a videographer named Will, Sir Tom and Mike, the photographer. At right is Sir Tom and Jacqui Cohen, the event’s host. Love Tom’s diamond-studded tie, don’t you?)
REVIEW: The ultimate ladies’ man
By: Melissa Martin/Updated: June 10 at 09:47 PM CDT/Winnipeg Free Press
There was a Saturday Night Live skit a few years back, where Tim Meadows played a silk-robed Lothario who sipped Courvoisier and took viewer calls on his public television show. Every time a woman called in, Meadows’ character would cock his eyebrow wickedly. “Ooooooh, it’s a lady,” he’d coo.
This, I’m pretty certain, is Tom Jones’ real life inner monologue.
For over 40 years, the Welsh singer has famously winked his way across the world, charming his mostly female audiences with nary more than a waggle of his hips and a catalogue of frankly sexual songs.
(more…)







From 


